Place an Order or Contact Us

Order your pies, cookies and coffee today! Our friendly customer service representatives are standing by to take your order.

(866) 919-5956 toll-free order line.

Do you have comments or questions for us? Please feel free to email customer service using the following form:


Send us your communication by mail:
Amish Pie
P. O. Box 172
Walnut Creek, OH 44687

Alternative text
Alternative text
The cultural mindset is to use what you have on hand, so when it comes to baking, that means fresh ingredients.
Learn More About The Amish